Film · Not named in the listing · 2010
The White Ribbon
53Watch it awake.
I'd watch it once the little ones are down: a cold black-and-white village breeding the next harm, and our notes barely sketch it.
Pass it on
The review
It is Haneke's black-and-white German village right before the First World War, framed as mystery-drama about evil taking root in ordinary family and church life. The notes we have are thin: no shot to point at, no spoken line, only the claim that religious and political terror grow from the same ground.
What holds up is the seriousness of that premise. It will not costume the past or hand you a hero. For a house the question is plain: if strict order and piety can raise the next public cruelty, what are we actually handing on when we demand quiet children and unbroken rules—and should a thirteen-year-old meet that alone?
The glance
Industry and Courage and Temperance are the thin ones.
Does anyone here do a real job, and does that job matter?
This phone is set for a grown person, just me. Change the ages.
The eight
- 4Industry
Village labor is implied by the setting; the notes never show a job that turns the plot.
- 8Household
Family is named as the dark ground of the story, not scenery.
- 7Piety
Haneke ties the harm to religious order as much as to politics.
- 2Courage
Nothing in the given notes shows a person risking what they would miss.
- 6Republic
A whole eastern village's habits stand in for the public before the war.
- 3Temperance
The listing never shows appetite refused or indulged on screen.
- 5Truth
It is sold as mystery, so concealment matters, yet no bill is described.
- 7Stewardship
It asks what kind of people that village leaves for the century ahead.
Where to watch
Finding the page.
Live Historic · The White Ribbon · 53IMDb
