Skip to content

Nothing on this shelf sits in this range.

Live HistoricSee what matters.

Series · Hulu · 2022

The Girl from Plainville

The Girl from Plainville

44Leave it.

Heavy true-crime about the texting case; leave it if the kids are still up.

Take controlThis scores 44. If you do not want The Girl from Plainville in the house, the steps are on Hulu. Block it

Pass it on

The review

This is the Hulu dramatization of Michelle Carter and Conrad Roy III, the Massachusetts case where encouragement by text and phone ended in his death and her involuntary-manslaughter conviction. The listing gives you that true-crime spine, the Esquire source, and the leads—Elle Fanning, Colton Ryan, Chloë Sevigny—not a single invented scene.

Performances carry the weight and keep the families human instead of cartoon. What it costs if you leave it on is a night fixed on suicide pressure, teen isolation, and a courtroom that will not shake off easy; younger kids and anyone raw on that subject should be out of the room.

The glance

Industry and Piety and Courage and Temperance and Stewardship are the thin ones.

  1. 2Industry
  2. 7Household
  3. 4Piety
  4. 3Courage
  5. 8Republic
  6. 2Temperance
  7. 6Truth
  8. 3Stewardship

Does anyone here do a real job, and does that job matter?

This phone is set for a grown person, just me. Change the ages.

The eight

  1. 2
    Industry

    School and small jobs sit in the background; the case, not work, drives every hour.

  2. 7
    Household

    Parents and the two teens are the whole frame, not side decoration for a plot.

  3. 4
    Piety

    Conscience shows up late, mostly as courtroom and family fallout, not a clean stop.

  4. 3
    Courage

    Almost no one risks a good they would miss; the harm is pressure, not brave cost.

  5. 8
    Republic

    The town, the trial, and the manslaughter charge are the spine of the story.

  6. 2
    Temperance

    You are pulled toward the next message and the next reveal more than any restraint.

  7. 6
    Truth

    Texts and calls are weighed as real acts; the conviction is the bill the show circles.

  8. 3
    Stewardship

    What remains is grief, a record, and two broken houses—not much handed forward whole.

Do this

This week, read one primary news report on the actual Carter verdict with your co-parent before anyone hits play.

Where to watch

Finding the page.

Live Historic · The Girl from Plainville · 44IMDb tt12851512