Skip to content
Live Historic

Nothing on this shelf sits in this range.

Live HistoricSee what matters.

Film · Not named in the listing · 2009

New York, I Love You

31Leave it.

It's eleven short love pieces set across New York's boroughs; the listing gave almost nothing past that setup, so I can't honestly tell you the evening pays off.

Take controlThis scores 31. New York, I Love You cannot be blocked by name on this shelf. The lock is the phone. Block it

Pass it on

The review

What you get is a chain of short films, each by another director, all circling love inside New York's five boroughs—the same Cities of Love idea that followed Paris, je t'aime. The good is the simple frame: many hands, one city, brief tries at affection. That is all the listing actually hands over.

No scene, job, vow, or child is described, so a house cannot tell whether any short treats love as something that stays or just passes. A thirteen-year-old finding it alone raises the plain question: is this evening built for the people who live here, or only for the next click through romance shorts?

The glance

Industry and Household and Piety and Courage and Republic and Temperance and Truth and Stewardship are the thin ones.

  1. 3Industry
  2. 4Household
  3. 2Piety
  4. 3Courage
  5. 4Republic
  6. 3Temperance
  7. 3Truth
  8. 3Stewardship

Does anyone here do a real job, and does that job matter?

This phone is set for a grown person, just me. Change the ages.

The eight

  1. 3
    Industry

    The listing never shows a job that drives a short; work stays off-screen.

  2. 4
    Household

    Love is the subject, yet no marriage, parent, or child is shown as a lasting life.

  3. 2
    Piety

    Nothing in the given setup lets conscience halt a choice on screen.

  4. 3
    Courage

    No one is shown risking a person or place they would actually miss.

  5. 4
    Republic

    The city is backdrop; no debt to neighbor, law, or town is spelled out.

  6. 3
    Temperance

    An anthology of romance shorts trains the next hit more than restraint.

  7. 3
    Truth

    No promise or lie is given room to hold or cost anyone.

  8. 3
    Stewardship

    What remains for anyone after the shorts is not in the material we got.

Do this

This week, watch one short with the youngest teen present and stop after it to name whether anyone in it kept a promise.

Where to watch

Finding the page.

Live Historic · New York, I Love You · 31IMDb