Skip to content
Live Historic

Nothing on this shelf sits in this range.

The Holy Bible, King James VersionThe Holy Bible, King James VersionThe Declaration of IndependenceThe Declaration of IndependenceCommon SenseCommon SenseLittle House on the PrairieLittle House on the PrairieRobinson CrusoeRobinson CrusoeThe New England PrimerThe New England PrimerThe Pilgrim's ProgressThe Pilgrim's ProgressA grandfather's warA grandfather's warA Little Pretty Pocket-BookA Little Pretty Pocket-BookA town's ghost storiesA town's ghost storiesBeauty and the BeastBeauty and the BeastBluebeardBluebeardChesterChesterCinderellaCinderellaJack and the BeanstalkJack and the BeanstalkLittle Red Riding HoodLittle Red Riding HoodThe Connecticut CourantThe Connecticut CourantThe Hiding PlaceThe Hiding PlaceThe History of Little Goody Two-ShoesThe History of Little Goody Two-ShoesThe OdysseyThe OdysseyThe Sunday pulpitThe Sunday pulpitA Man for All SeasonsA Man for All SeasonsLittle House in the Big WoodsLittle House in the Big WoodsWon't You Be My Neighbor?Won't You Be My Neighbor?A Change Is Gonna ComeA Change Is Gonna ComeA Christmas CarolA Christmas CarolIt's a Wonderful LifeIt's a Wonderful LifeLittle BritchesLittle BritchesAmazing GraceAmazing GraceCabriniCabriniSound of Hope: The Story of Possum TrotSound of Hope: The Story of Possum TrotWhen Calls the HeartWhen Calls the HeartA Love SupremeA Love SupremeAll Creatures Great and SmallAll Creatures Great and SmallCarry On, Mr. BowditchCarry On, Mr. BowditchCoat of Many ColorsCoat of Many ColorsJohn AdamsJohn AdamsLittle House on the PrairieLittle House on the PrairieMaster and CommanderMaster and CommanderTaking ChanceTaking ChanceThe Lord of the Rings: The Fellowship of the RingThe Lord of the Rings: The Fellowship of the RingTo Kill a MockingbirdTo Kill a MockingbirdDopesickDopesickGoodbye, Mr. ChipsGoodbye, Mr. ChipsLincolnLincolnLittle WomenLittle WomenPlaces in the HeartPlaces in the HeartTender MerciesTender MerciesThe Holy Bible, King James VersionThe Holy Bible, King James VersionThe Declaration of IndependenceThe Declaration of IndependenceCommon SenseCommon SenseLittle House on the PrairieLittle House on the PrairieRobinson CrusoeRobinson CrusoeThe New England PrimerThe New England PrimerThe Pilgrim's ProgressThe Pilgrim's ProgressA grandfather's warA grandfather's warA Little Pretty Pocket-BookA Little Pretty Pocket-BookA town's ghost storiesA town's ghost storiesBeauty and the BeastBeauty and the BeastBluebeardBluebeardChesterChesterCinderellaCinderellaJack and the BeanstalkJack and the BeanstalkLittle Red Riding HoodLittle Red Riding HoodThe Connecticut CourantThe Connecticut CourantThe Hiding PlaceThe Hiding PlaceThe History of Little Goody Two-ShoesThe History of Little Goody Two-ShoesThe OdysseyThe OdysseyThe Sunday pulpitThe Sunday pulpitA Man for All SeasonsA Man for All SeasonsLittle House in the Big WoodsLittle House in the Big WoodsWon't You Be My Neighbor?Won't You Be My Neighbor?A Change Is Gonna ComeA Change Is Gonna ComeA Christmas CarolA Christmas CarolIt's a Wonderful LifeIt's a Wonderful LifeLittle BritchesLittle BritchesAmazing GraceAmazing GraceCabriniCabriniSound of Hope: The Story of Possum TrotSound of Hope: The Story of Possum TrotWhen Calls the HeartWhen Calls the HeartA Love SupremeA Love SupremeAll Creatures Great and SmallAll Creatures Great and SmallCarry On, Mr. BowditchCarry On, Mr. BowditchCoat of Many ColorsCoat of Many ColorsJohn AdamsJohn AdamsLittle House on the PrairieLittle House on the PrairieMaster and CommanderMaster and CommanderTaking ChanceTaking ChanceThe Lord of the Rings: The Fellowship of the RingThe Lord of the Rings: The Fellowship of the RingTo Kill a MockingbirdTo Kill a MockingbirdDopesickDopesickGoodbye, Mr. ChipsGoodbye, Mr. ChipsLincolnLincolnLittle WomenLittle WomenPlaces in the HeartPlaces in the HeartTender MerciesTender Mercies

Every scored title on the desk, from 0 to 100. The number is the eight marks, added, divided by eight, times ten. Pick 80, 65, or under 45. Tap a picture to open it.

Live HistoricSee what matters.

Series · BBC iPlayer · 2023

Killing Sherlock: Lucy Worsley on the Case of Conan Doyle

Killing Sherlock: Lucy Worsley on the Case of Conan Doyle

53Watch it awake.

Three episodes of Worsley on why Doyle resented the detective who made him rich; one night if you like creator-versus-creation history.

Pass it on

The review

It is Lucy Worsley, a lifelong fan, walking the parallel lives of Sherlock Holmes and Arthur Conan Doyle in three episodes: the detective who never dies on the page and the writer who grew to hate the cash and the cage. The good part is the clear through-line—fame, formula, and the attempt to stop the machine—without turning Doyle into a cartoon villain.

Do you want an evening on how a made-up man can own his maker, or would you rather spend it on something that does not keep pulling you toward the next adaptation? If Holmes already lives on your shelf, this earns the watch; if not, it will feel like homework about someone else’s obsession.

The glance

Household and Piety and Temperance are the thin ones.

  1. 7Industry
  2. 3Household
  3. 4Piety
  4. 6Courage
  5. 5Republic
  6. 4Temperance
  7. 7Truth
  8. 6Stewardship

Is a marriage, a parent, or a child a real life here, or just a prop?

This phone is set for a grown person, just me. Change the ages.

The eight

  1. 7
    Industry

    Doyle’s writing is treated as paid labor that built fame and a trap he could not quit.

  2. 3
    Household

    Family life stays mostly off-stage; the bond on screen is author to character, not spouse or child.

  3. 4
    Piety

    Conscience appears as Doyle’s unease with the fame machine, not as prayer or creed.

  4. 6
    Courage

    Doyle risks the income and the audience by trying to kill the character readers loved.

  5. 5
    Republic

    Law and detection sit in the fiction; civic duty is background, not the series’ center.

  6. 4
    Temperance

    The show feeds the next clue and next episode more than it models refusal.

  7. 7
    Truth

    Promises to readers and the cost of the Holmes myth get weighed against Doyle’s own words.

  8. 6
    Stewardship

    What remains is the canon and the question of who owns a character after the author.

Do this

This week read one original Holmes story aloud at the table and note one line Doyle might have resented writing.

Where to watch

Finding the page.

Live Historic · Killing Sherlock: Lucy Worsley on the Case of Conan Doyle · 53IMDb tt29291706