Skip to content

Nothing on this page sits inside the line. Drag either end, or choose All.

Live HistoricSee what matters.

Series · BBC Four · 2009

It's Only a Theory

33Leave it.

Dry Hat Trick panel comedy on BBC Four: experts get needled and voted keep-or-bin. Fine if that is all you wanted; thin past the setup.

Take controlThis scores 33. It's Only a Theory cannot be blocked by name on this shelf. The lock is the phone. Block it

Pass it on

The review

It's a 2009 BBC Four panel game from Hat Trick. Highly qualified people submit theories, then Andy Hamilton, Reginald D. Hunter, and a guest pick them apart and vote keep or bin. We only get that setup—no episode beat, no line that landed, no face that flinched.

The good part is real expertise walking into comic fire instead of a lecture. The rest is thin. If a nine-year-old is asking and a five-year-old is still in the room, you decide whether the fun is testing ideas or just needling smart people, and whether that habit sticks after the set.

The glance

Industry and Household and Piety and Courage and Republic and Temperance and Stewardship are the thin ones.

  1. 4Industry
  2. 1Household
  3. 2Piety
  4. 3Courage
  5. 4Republic
  6. 3Temperance
  7. 6Truth
  8. 3Stewardship

Does anyone here do a real job, and does that job matter?

This phone is set for a grown person, just me. Change the ages.

The eight

  1. 4
    Industry

    Qualified pros pitch real theories; the on-screen job is the pitch, not only the joke.

  2. 1
    Household

    No marriage, parent, or child lives here; only the panel and guest fill the room.

  3. 2
    Piety

    Conscience never stops anyone on screen; the scrutiny stays comic.

  4. 3
    Courage

    Experts risk a public bin of their idea and lose face if it goes.

  5. 4
    Republic

    The vote is a shared call on which theory stays; town and neighbor stay offstage.

  6. 3
    Temperance

    The format pushes the next theory and the next laugh; little restraint shown.

  7. 6
    Truth

    The game is whether a claim survives exam; keep or discard is the bill.

  8. 3
    Stewardship

    A voted list of theories is what remains; nothing left for households after.

Do this

This week write one claim you hold, read it aloud at supper, and let the table vote keep or bin with no phone.

Where to watch

Finding the page.

Live Historic · It's Only a Theory · 33IMDb