Film · Not named in the listing · 2010
Charlie St. Cloud
45Watch it awake.
A thin premise film: dead-brother promise versus living girl; Zac Efron vehicle, not much else on the page.
Pass it on
The review
What you get is a supernatural drama built on one bind: Charlie still keeps a promise to the younger brother who died in their car crash, and a living romance asks him to let that go. The good in it is plain—the brother bond is treated as real weight, not a prop, and a vow to the dead can still check him.
We only have that bare choice on the page, no job, town, or later fruit filled in. For a house where a thirteen-year-old may find it alone and a nine-year-old next, the question is whether you want them sitting with grief, a ghost-pact, and first love before anyone can talk it through with them.
The glance
Industry and Republic and Temperance and Stewardship are the thin ones.
Does anyone here do a real job, and does that job matter?
This phone is set for a grown person, just me. Change the ages.
The eight
- 2Industry
No trade or craft is shown mattering; the listing never puts Charlie at real work.
- 6Household
The dead younger brother and the living mother are the stake, not scenery.
- 7Piety
A promise to the dead brother can still stop him; conscience has a veto.
- 5Courage
He risks the girl he wants, or the pact he would miss; both cost him.
- 1Republic
No neighbor, law, or town claim appears in what we were given.
- 4Temperance
The pull is the next romance against the old vow; appetite is the test.
- 8Truth
The brother’s promise is the hinge; breaking it would come with a bill.
- 3Stewardship
What remains for anyone after the choice is barely sketched here.
Where to watch
Finding the page.
Live Historic · Charlie St. Cloud · 45IMDb
