Skip to content

Nothing on this page sits inside the line. Drag either end, or choose All.

Live HistoricSee what matters.

Film · Not named in the listing · 2010

Charlie St. Cloud

45Watch it awake.

A thin premise film: dead-brother promise versus living girl; Zac Efron vehicle, not much else on the page.

Pass it on

The review

What you get is a supernatural drama built on one bind: Charlie still keeps a promise to the younger brother who died in their car crash, and a living romance asks him to let that go. The good in it is plain—the brother bond is treated as real weight, not a prop, and a vow to the dead can still check him.

We only have that bare choice on the page, no job, town, or later fruit filled in. For a house where a thirteen-year-old may find it alone and a nine-year-old next, the question is whether you want them sitting with grief, a ghost-pact, and first love before anyone can talk it through with them.

The glance

Industry and Republic and Temperance and Stewardship are the thin ones.

  1. 2Industry
  2. 6Household
  3. 7Piety
  4. 5Courage
  5. 1Republic
  6. 4Temperance
  7. 8Truth
  8. 3Stewardship

Does anyone here do a real job, and does that job matter?

This phone is set for a grown person, just me. Change the ages.

The eight

  1. 2
    Industry

    No trade or craft is shown mattering; the listing never puts Charlie at real work.

  2. 6
    Household

    The dead younger brother and the living mother are the stake, not scenery.

  3. 7
    Piety

    A promise to the dead brother can still stop him; conscience has a veto.

  4. 5
    Courage

    He risks the girl he wants, or the pact he would miss; both cost him.

  5. 1
    Republic

    No neighbor, law, or town claim appears in what we were given.

  6. 4
    Temperance

    The pull is the next romance against the old vow; appetite is the test.

  7. 8
    Truth

    The brother’s promise is the hinge; breaking it would come with a bill.

  8. 3
    Stewardship

    What remains for anyone after the choice is barely sketched here.

Do this

This week, say out loud one promise you still keep to someone gone, and whether it still fits the living.

Where to watch

Finding the page.

Live Historic · Charlie St. Cloud · 45IMDb