Skip to content

Nothing on this shelf sits in this range.

Live HistoricSee what matters.

Series · Hallmark Mystery · 2020

A Martha's Vineyard Mystery

51Watch it awake.

Fine for a low-stakes Hallmark night if you want a hurt cop fishing on the Vineyard and getting pulled back in; skip it if you need real weight.

Pass it on

The review

What it is: a retired Boston detective living in his late father's place on Martha's Vineyard, trying to fish after injury and loss on the job, until a mysterious visitor turns up dead and the local police chief—a family friend—recruits him.

The good part is the return to a father's house and the reluctant yes to a neighbor in the law. What it costs is how little else is filled in; the people and the stakes stay mostly off the page. The question for a house is whether that quiet island pull is enough for an evening when the work and the home life are only sketched.

The glance

Piety and Temperance are the thin ones.

  1. 6Industry
  2. 5Household
  3. 3Piety
  4. 5Courage
  5. 7Republic
  6. 4Temperance
  7. 5Truth
  8. 6Stewardship

Can conscience actually stop someone, or is reverence only in the shot so it can be mocked?

This phone is set for a grown person, just me. Change the ages.

The eight

  1. 6
    Industry

    Jeff left real detective work injured; fishing is the job he tries to keep.

  2. 5
    Household

    He lives in his late father's home; the chief is named a family friend.

  3. 3
    Piety

    The given setup never shows conscience stopping anyone mid-choice.

  4. 5
    Courage

    He risks the quiet he came for when he agrees to help the chief.

  5. 7
    Republic

    He still owes the island law enough to leave the dock for a neighbor.

  6. 4
    Temperance

    The format keeps you waiting on the next body more than on restraint.

  7. 5
    Truth

    A death opens the case; no clear bill for a lie is shown here.

  8. 6
    Stewardship

    Father's house and the fishing life are what remain after the city job.

Do this

This week, oil or mend one tool or rod that still sits in a relative's house you keep.

Where to watch

Finding the page.

Live Historic · A Martha's Vineyard Mystery · 51IMDb